Rookie Cards

The 40 Best Young Guns Rookie Cards to Collect Since 2020

Hockey card collecting is booming, and we’re seeing more collectors from baseball, basketball, and football discovering what makes hockey cards so exciting.

Two developments have helped fuel that interest. First, Macklin Celebrini has emerged as a potential generational superstar, sending demand for his rookie cards soaring. Second, Team USA’s dramatic Olympic gold-medal victory over Canada in February 2026, capped by Jack Hughes‘ overtime winner, brought renewed attention to hockey throughout the United States.

For collectors entering the hockey card market, collecting the best Upper Deck’s Young Guns rookie cards remain one of the most popular places to start. But which modern Young Guns cards are the most desirable?

This is my personal ranking of the 40 best Young Guns rookie cards from 2020 through 2026, including six goaltenders, eight defensemen, and 26 forwards.

You can find links to all the best Young Guns rookie cards from all-time here!

How I Ranked The Best Young Guns Rookie Cards

This isn’t simply a ranking of the NHL’s best players. If it were, players such as Moritz Seider, Tim Stützle, Leo Carlsson, and Kirill Kaprizov would rank higher. Instead, I’ve considered several factors:

  • Collectability: How much interest does the player generate among hockey card collectors?
  • Market appeal: Players in passionate hockey markets, particularly Montreal and Toronto, often enjoy additional demand.
  • Young Guns demand: How desirable is the player’s flagship Upper Deck rookie card?
  • Long-term potential: Does the player have the talent and opportunity to become a lasting NHL star?
  • Current performance: How has the player performed through approximately the first quarter of the 2026–27 season?

These rankings represent my assessment of the hobby as of November 18, 2026. Player statistics and rankings will naturally change as the season progresses.

As a part of the eBay Partner Network, our site makes a commission if you buy through our links. Thank you!

Countdown: 6 Best Young Guns Rookie Cards For Goalies Since 2020

Goaltenders can be particularly challenging for hockey card collectors. Their performance can fluctuate, and even talented young goalies sometimes take years to establish themselves. Still, these six netminders stand out.

6. Yaroslav Askarov — San Jose Sharks

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats:
.888 save percentage, 0 shutouts

5. Jakub Dobeš — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Extended Series
2026–27 stats: .852 save percentage, 0 shutouts

4. Jake Oettinger — Dallas Stars

Young Guns: 2020 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: .902 save percentage, 4 shutouts

3. Jeremy Swayman — Boston Bruins

Young Guns: 2021 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: .906 save percentage, 1 shutout

2. Jesper Wallstedt — Minnesota Wild

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: .924 save percentage, 0 shutouts

Many consider Wallstedt the best young goalie in the NHL right now. If he played in Montreal, he might occupy the top spot on this list.

His mental toughness, positioning, and ability to control rebounds make him an outstanding young goaltender. He has the qualities needed to become an all-time great if he continues developing along his current path.

1. Jacob Fowler — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series
2026–27 stats: .923 save percentage, 2 shutouts

Jakub Dobeš began the season as Montreal’s starting goaltender, but Fowler outplayed him early and established himself as the starter. At just 21 years old, Fowler has already drawn comparisons to Carey Price. His positioning, confidence, and early success suggest he could be Montreal’s goalie of the future.

Playing for the Canadiens gives Fowler a considerable collectability advantage. Even if he eventually splits starts with Dobeš, his age and long-term potential make him the more attractive option to many collectors. Fowler has also entered the Calder Trophy conversation. If he maintains this level of performance, he could become the first goaltender to win NHL Rookie of the Year honors since 2009.

Countdown: 8 Best Young Guns Rookie Cards For Defensemen Since 2020

Defensemen don’t always receive the same hobby attention as high-scoring forwards. However, the emergence of several exciting offensive defensemen has made this position increasingly interesting to collectors.

8. Moritz Seider — Detroit Red Wings

Young Guns: 2021 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 1 goal, 12 assists, 13 points

7. Jackson LaCombe — Anaheim Ducks

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 1 goal, 23 assists, 24 points

6. Brock Faber — Minnesota Wild

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 1

Faber missed the opening quarter of the 2026–27 season because of injury, but his long-term potential keeps him among my favorite modern Young Guns defensemen.

5. Jake Sanderson — Ottawa Senators

Young Guns: 2022 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 1 goal, 9 assists, 10 points

Sanderson missed eight games with an injury during the opening portion of the season.

4. Cole Hutson — Washington Capitals

Young Guns: 2026 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 5 goals, 10 assists, 15 points

3. Luke Hughes — New Jersey Devils

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 6 goals, 8 assists, 14 points

2. Lane Hutson — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 3 goals, 16 assists, 19 points

2024 Upper Deck Lane Hutson

Lane Hutson has quickly established himself as one of the NHL’s most exciting offensive defensemen. At just 5-foot-9 and 162 pounds, Hutson makes up for his lack of size with exceptional skating, vision, passing, and decision-making. He uses so many head fakes that he sometimes looks like Michael Jackson in the Thriller video!

What makes his story even more appealing is that Montreal selected him 62nd overall in the 2022 NHL Draft. He wasn’t supposed to become one of the league’s most dynamic defensemen, but that’s exactly what he’s becoming.

Watching Hutson quarterback Montreal’s power play or create opportunities during three-on-three overtime is something special. His combination of talent, underdog appeal, and the Montreal market makes his Young Guns rookie card particularly desirable.

1. Matthew Schaefer — New York Islanders

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 9 goals, 15 assists, 24 points

What makes Matthew Schaefer and Lane Hutson different from most defensemen? They sometimes look like highly skilled forwards who happen to be playing defense.

At 6-foot-2, Schaefer is bigger and more physical than Hutson. He also possesses outstanding straight-line speed, allowing him to make the kind of exciting end-to-end rushes that bring back memories of Bobby Orr. Schaefer has a particularly impressive shot and a natural ability to score goals. Early in the season, he’s producing at a pace that would be remarkable for any defenseman, let alone a teenager.

The biggest question surrounding his collectability is his team. Montreal’s exciting young roster appears positioned for sustained playoff success, while the Islanders face a less certain future. If New York builds a stronger supporting cast around Schaefer, his Young Guns rookie card could become one of the defining modern hockey cards.

Countdown: The 26 Best Young Guns Rookie Cards For Forwards Since 2020

Now we reach the forwards, where the biggest names and some of the most desirable modern Young Guns rookie cards reside. These rankings reflect both on-ice talent and the demand I see from collectors.

26. Anton Frondell — Chicago Blackhawks

Young Guns: 2026 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 4 goals, 7 assists, 11 points

25. Frank Nazar — Chicago Blackhawks

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 10 goals, 2 assists, 12 points

24. Kirill Marchenko — Toronto Maple Leafs

Young Guns: 2022 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats:
6 goals, 8 assists, 14 points

Marchenko’s Young Guns card pictures him with his former team, the Columbus Blue Jackets.

23. Alexis Lafrenière — New York Rangers

Young Guns: 2020 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 10 goals, 12 assists, 22 points

22. James Hagens — Boston Bruins

Young Guns: 2026 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 6 goals, 6 assists, 12 points

Hagens suffered an injury shortly before the season’s quarter mark.

21. Ryan Leonard — Washington Capitals

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 8 goals, 7 assists, 15 points

20. Easton Cowan — Toronto Maple Leafs

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 7 goals, 9 assists, 16 points

19. Jackson Blake — Carolina Hurricanes

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 6 goals, 15 assists, 21 points

18. Jason Robertson — Dallas Stars

Young Guns: 2020 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 10 goals, 14 assists, 24 points

17. Matvei Michkov — Philadelphia Flyers

2026–27 stats: 11 goals, 5 assists, 16 points

2024 Upper Deck Matvei Michkov

16. Michael Misa — San Jose Sharks

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 4 goals, 8 assists, 12 points

15. Tim Stützle — Ottawa Senators

Young Guns: 2020 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 11 goals, 14 assists, 25 points

2020-21 Upper Deck Series 2 Tim Stutzle

Stützle might be the most underrated young forward in the NHL. Through the early part of this season, he’s among the league leaders in average ice time for forwards, alongside Connor McDavid and Macklin Celebrini. With Brady Tkachuk no longer in Ottawa, Stützle has an opportunity to become an even more prominent offensive leader. He has the potential to produce 100 points and 100 hits in a season, combining offensive skill with a physical element that makes him especially valuable.

If he played in a larger hockey market, I believe he’d rank among the top six players on this list.

14. Will Smith — San Jose Sharks

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Extended Series
2026–27 stats: 8 goals, 10 assists, 18 points

Will Smith isn’t simply Robin to Macklin Celebrini’s Batman. He’s an elite young player with enormous long-term potential of his own. Playing alongside Celebrini on San Jose’s top line and first power-play unit gives Smith a tremendous opportunity to produce impressive offensive numbers. His creativity, passing, hockey intelligence, and ability to draw defenders before finding open teammates have drawn comparisons to former Sharks great Joe Thornton.

13. Logan Stankoven — Carolina Hurricanes

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 11 goals, 9 assists, 20 points

At just 5-foot-8 and 165 pounds, Logan Stankoven proves that size isn’t everything in hockey. He was one of Carolina’s most productive players during its playoff run last season, recording 11 goals and 16 points in 16 games. Stankoven combines excellent hockey intelligence, outstanding skating in tight spaces, and an extremely quick shot release.

Along with teammate Jackson Blake, he’s become an important part of Carolina’s offense. His playing style reminds me of smaller, high-energy stars such as Theo Fleury and Martin St. Louis. Stankoven’s Young Guns card still pictures him with Dallas, but his future in Carolina looks exciting.

12. Logan Cooley — Utah Mammoth

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Extended Series
2026–27 stats: 11 goals, 11 assists, 22 points

2023 Upper Deck Logan Cooley

I can’t be the only collector who wishes Logan Cooley’s Young Guns card pictured him wearing Utah’s uniforms instead of Arizona’s!

Cooley’s hockey story has an interesting connection to Sidney Crosby. As a five-year-old growing up in Pittsburgh, he participated in Crosby’s Little Penguins Learn to Play Hockey program.

Years later, Cooley scored a hat trick against Crosby’s Penguins.

Cooley is an exceptionally fast skater and a creative playmaking center. His speed and intelligence have helped make Utah’s power play one of the league’s most dangerous early in the season.

He’s already demonstrated a knack for scoring hat tricks, and his combination of speed and scoring ability makes him an exciting player to collect.

11. Leo Carlsson — Anaheim Ducks

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 6 goals, 21 assists, 27 points

Leo Carlsson is proving that he’s one of the NHL’s elite young playmakers.

He’s primarily a pass-first center, which means his assist totals may attract more attention than his goal totals. Unfortunately, collectors often place greater value on goal scorers.

Carlsson has outstanding finishers around him, including Cutter Gauthier and Beckett Sennecke.

His playmaking ability has helped Anaheim build one of the league’s best power plays, and he’s on pace for a significant jump in production.

If he reaches 100 points, collectors may begin giving him the attention his talent deserves.

10. Wyatt Johnston — Dallas Stars

Young Guns: 2022 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 6 goals, 13 assists, 19 points

2022-23 Upper Deck Series 2 Wyatt Johnston

Wyatt Johnston possesses elite hockey intelligence and an exceptional ability to read plays. Like Macklin Celebrini, he relentlessly pursues loose pucks and contributes throughout the entire rink.

Johnston is an outstanding two-way center who combines offensive production with defensive responsibility. Interestingly, collectors seem to favor Johnston over teammate Jason Robertson, even though Robertson is an accomplished goal-scoring winger. That makes Johnston a fascinating example of a player whose overall game helps drive his collectibility.

9. Juraj Slafkovský — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2022 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 2 goals, 11 assists, 13 points

Juraj Slafkovský is the prototype of the modern NHL power forward. At 6-foot-4, he combines size, skill, and a strong all-around game.

The former first-overall draft pick plays on Montreal’s top line and first power-play unit, giving him plenty of opportunities to produce. He might not score as many goals as Cole Caufield, but his overall impact goes well beyond the scoresheet. And, of course, playing for Montreal gives his Young Guns card a significant collectibility boost.

8. Kirill Kaprizov — Minnesota Wild

Young Guns: 2020 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 17 goals, 18 assists, 35 points

Kirill “The Thrill” Kaprizov is one of the most talented offensive players in the NHL. Elite skating, incredible hands, outstanding hockey intelligence, and an ability to avoid defenders make him a nightmare for opposing teams. At 29, he isn’t showing signs of slowing down.

His tremendous start has put him on a potential 60-goal pace, a milestone only a handful of players have reached in recent decades. Because Kaprizov didn’t enter the NHL until age 23, his career totals may never match players who started much younger. However, his per-game production places him among some of hockey’s greatest offensive talents.

It’s remarkable that Minnesota selected him 135th overall in the 2015 NHL Draft. His Young Guns collectability has often lagged behind his actual talent. A historic scoring season or deep playoff run could change that.

7. Beckett Sennecke — Anaheim Ducks

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series
2026–27 stats: 12 goals, 14 assists, 26 points

Beckett Sennecke has already shown that he belongs among the NHL’s most promising young forwards. The third-overall selection in the 2024 NHL Draft combines a 6-foot-3 frame with excellent hands, stickhandling, vision, and shooting ability. He demonstrated his scoring potential last season, finishing with 23 goals and 60 points.

Although Cutter Gauthier currently plays alongside Leo Carlsson on Anaheim’s top line, Sennecke joins them on the Ducks’ dangerous first power-play unit. If Sennecke eventually becomes a regular linemate of Carlsson, his goal-scoring numbers could climb even higher.

6. Matt Boldy — Minnesota Wild

Young Guns: 2022 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 10 goals, 11 assists, 21 points

Minnesota has one of the strongest rosters in the NHL, and Matt Boldy is a major reason why. At 6-foot-2, Boldy combines size with outstanding hockey intelligence, excellent hands, strong passing, and an impressive shot. He has already demonstrated his ability to perform on big stages, including the Olympics and Stanley Cup playoffs.

Playing alongside Kirill Kaprizov gives Boldy plenty of offensive opportunities. With Quinn Hughes also contributing to Minnesota’s power play, the Wild have the potential to make a deep postseason run. That additional playoff exposure could make Boldy’s Young Guns rookie card even more desirable.

5. Cole Caufield — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2021 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 12 goals, 7 assists, 19 points

Cole Caufield might be small at 5-foot-8, but he has an enormous impact on Montreal’s offense. Known as “Mr. Saturday Night,” Caufield has developed a reputation for scoring when the game is on the line. His remarkable overtime production and ability to deliver game-winning goals make him one of the NHL’s most exciting finishers.

Like Logan Stankoven, Caufield reminds me of smaller, energetic stars such as Theo Fleury and Martin St. Louis. With Montreal’s talented young roster surrounding him, I believe Caufield has the potential to score 45 goals regularly, with an occasional 50-goal season. Other players might offer a more complete all-around game, but Caufield’s goal-scoring ability and the Montreal market make his Young Guns card especially collectible.

4. Cutter Gauthier — Anaheim Ducks

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 18 goals, 7 assists, 25 points

2024 Upper Deck Cutter Gauthier

Cutter Gauthier has one of the best shots in the NHL. At 6-foot-3 and 205 pounds, he’s a highly skilled power forward with impressive speed, a willingness to shoot, and the ability to finish scoring opportunities. He’s playing on Anaheim’s first line and first power-play unit, benefiting from the creativity of Leo Carlsson and the Ducks’ rapidly improving offense.

And let’s face it: In baseball card collecting, home runs attract attention. In hockey, it’s goals.

Gauthier’s tremendous start has him on a remarkable scoring pace. Even allowing for inevitable cold stretches, he looks capable of producing another outstanding goal-scoring season. I ranked him aggressively last year, and some people thought that was ridiculous. One critic said the prediction would “age like milk.” Well, maybe it’s aging more like fine wine!

Gauthier is establishing himself as one of the NHL’s premier goal scorers.

3. Ivan Demidov — Montreal Canadiens

Young Guns: 2025 Upper Deck Series 1
2026–27 stats: 1 goal, 1 assist, 2 points

Yes, that’s three Canadiens players in my top nine! The Montreal factor is real, and Ivan Demidov might be one of the best examples of how market demand and future potential influence hockey card prices. Demidov possesses incredible puck control, creativity, and offensive instincts. His ability to handle the puck and maneuver around defenders brings back memories of Pavel Datsyuk.

Unfortunately, a broken ankle sidelined him for much of the opening quarter of the season. But his Young Guns card remains highly desirable because collectors recognize his enormous potential.

Demidov is still only 20 years old, and his prices already reflect expectations of future stardom. If he develops into the player many believe he can become, his Young Guns card could eventually challenge for the second spot on this list.

2. Connor Bedard — Chicago Blackhawks

Young Guns: 2023 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 7 goals, 11 assists, 18 points

Bedard remains one of the most recognizable young players in hockey. He possesses an incredibly quick shot, outstanding goal-scoring instincts, and the advantage of playing for an Original Six franchise in a major American sports market. However, durability remains a concern.

Bedard’s relatively small frame and injury history raise questions about his ability to withstand the physical demands of a long NHL season. If he can remain healthy, his potential as an elite goal scorer is undeniable. Chicago is also assembling a stronger young supporting cast, including Anton Frondell, Oliver Moore, and Frank Nazar.

One particularly interesting collecting fact: Bedard’s Young Guns rookie card is among the most heavily graded modern hockey cards, reflecting just how much attention he has received from collectors. His popularity is enormous, but the number of graded examples is also something collectors should consider.

1. Macklin Celebrini — San Jose Sharks

Young Guns: 2024 Upper Deck Series 2
2026–27 stats: 9 goals, 18 assists, 27 points

I’ve heard Macklin Celebrini described as having the skills of a first-overall draft pick and the work ethic of a fourth-line grinder. I think that’s a pretty accurate description. Ever since I first watched Celebrini play in person, I’ve been calling him Sidney Crosby 2.0. He possesses an outstanding 200-foot game, an almost relentless desire to win every loose puck, incredible vision, and the ability to both create scoring opportunities and finish them himself.

Just as importantly, he has an infectious personality that makes him easy for fans to embrace. There’s also an interesting connection between Celebrini and Crosby. Celebrini lived with and learned from former Sharks great Joe Thornton early in his NHL career, much like Crosby benefited from living with and being mentored by Mario Lemieux.

Celebrini is already producing at an elite level, and San Jose has surrounded him with an exciting collection of young offensive talent. If the Sharks can strengthen their defense, I believe Celebrini could lead them into regular playoff contention for years to come. For me, he’s the clear No. 1 atop our list of the best Young Guns rookie cards to collect from the 2020–2026 era.

Final Thoughts: Which Modern Young Guns Rookie Cards Should You Collect?

The hockey card market has changed considerably since 2020.

Players such as Bedard and Celebrini have attracted tremendous attention, while emerging stars like Schaefer, Lane Hutson, and Fowler are giving collectors exciting new names to pursue.

Remember, though, that the best hockey player isn’t always the player with the most valuable rookie card. Market size, team popularity, scoring ability, playoff exposure, and collector demand all influence prices. That’s why I believe it’s important to look beyond statistics when deciding which Young Guns cards belong in your collection.

Whether you’re chasing the biggest names or looking for talented players who haven’t received the hobby attention they deserve, there are plenty of exciting Young Guns rookie cards to collect.

Check out our page on the Best NHL Rookie Cards Ever!

Who do you think should rank higher among the best Young Guns rookie cards in the past few years? And which player do you think deserves to be ranked lower? Share your thoughts in the comments!

Randy Litzinger

Recent Posts

9 Best 2026 Prizm WNBA Rookie Cards

From Olivia Miles and Azzi Fudd to some surprising breakout stars, we rank the best…

7 days ago

8 Best 2026-27 Topps Basketball Rookie Cards: RC Rankings!

Picking up the best 2026-27 Topps Basketball Rookie Cards is a great way to build…

3 weeks ago

6 Best 2026 Upper Deck Series 1 Rookies Cards: Ranking Young Guns!

Improve your hockey card collection by picking up some of the best 2026 Upper Deck…

1 month ago

Ranking the 6 Best 2026 Topps Update Rookie Cards To Chase +1 Bonus Guy!

As the MLB year comes to a close, we rank the 6 Best 2026 Topps…

2 months ago

Top 50 Junk Wax Football Cards Everyone Needs!

Collecting the best Junk Wax Football Cards is a great way to connect to your…

2 months ago

Best MLB Rookie Cards From Each Year!

Looking for the best Topps baseball cards from each set, each year? It's a common…

3 months ago

This website uses cookies.